‘Mnangagwa is out of order, I’m going to bill him’ – SA health MEC fumes

Must Try

Trending

South African Limpopo Health MEC Dr Phophi Ramathuba has proposed sending a bill every month to the Zimbabwean government for all patients treated in hospitals in her province.

This comes a week after a video went viral of Ramathuba harassing a Zimbabwean patient at a hospital in Bela Bela accusing her of depleting her health budget.

In the latest video, she is seen telling a pregnant woman that the presence of Zimbabweans in her country in need of healthcare, running away from collapsed hospitals, is an indication of President Emmerson Mnangagwa’s leadership failure.

“Mnangagwa is out of order. He must do his work. I’m going to bill him,” she fumed.

Ramathuba then told health officials at the hospital that they should start sending bills to Harare for Zimbabwean patients treated in South Africa.

“Let’s really be serious, let’s cost all the hospitals and we send the bill (for foreign nationals) to their governments. All the deliveries in our hospitals, those that have left, we must send it to their governments and I will even issue a press statement that the Limpopo government has sent a bill of so many millions for this month for Zimbabwean nationals who cross the bridge to come and deliver,” she said.

The doctor said she was sympathetic with pregnant women or women with babies. She, however, said she was going to “bill Mnangagwa” because the patient had been transported by a local ambulance.

“For you, I must bill Mnangagwa because really I’m transporting you everytime to come here. What is Mnangagwa doing? He’s doing nothing and Phophi Ramathuba is doing his job.

“That’s what their nurses are writing. Zimbabweans are planning to give birth in South Africa because there’s nothing there. As midwives, we can’t turn away mothers and babies… they’re not the ones that made Mnangagwa president,” she added.

South African President Cyril Ramaphosa two days ago defended Ramathuba saying the issue of immigrants was serious all over the world.

This comes at a time when the health care system in Zimbabwe has deteriorated. Ruling Zanu-PF officials including the Health Minister who doubles as Vice President, Constantino Chiwenga are known for travelling to other countries whenever they get sick.

Related Articles

Moses Tofa is a Research Leader, political analyst, and self-critical Pan-Africanist. He holds a PhD in Politics from the University of Johannesburg and a PhD in Conflict Studies from the University of KwaZulu Natal. (Picture via Facebook - Moses Tofa)

Who will drive the bus: Mamvura or General Chiwenga? Will President Mnangagwa retire peacefully?...

0
Zimbabwe is at a crossroads where critical and cruel decisions are being made in the corridors of power. These decisions will determine the country’s direction for many years to come.
Chatunga Mugabe (28) and his co-accused, Tobias Mugabe Matonhodze (33), appeared before the Alexandra Magistrate’s Court in Johannesburg (Picture via SABC News)

Trauma, power and the unfinished healing of Zimbabwe: The case study of Mugabe and...

0
Zimbabwe’s modern political history is often narrated through elections, constitutional changes, economic collapse, land reform, sanctions, liberation-war heroism, tribalism, authoritarian rule and the emerging culture of a cargo cult.
US Donald Trump and Zimbabwean president Emmerson Mnangagwa (Picture via Shealeah Craighead, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons and X - @edmnangagwa)

Mnangagwa halts US$350 million health deal talks with Trump administration

0
HARARE - The Government of Zimbabwe has abandoned negotiations for a proposed US$350 million health funding agreement with the Donald Trump administration after Emmerson Mnangagwa directed officials to halt discussions, arguing that national sovereignty outweighed the potential benefits of the deal despite mounting challenges in the country’s health sector.
Caricature of Professor Jonathan Moyo (Picture via AI)

Those we reject: On exile, power, and the need for a home in Zimbabwean...

0
Zimbabwe stands once again at a constitutional crossroads. The ruling party’s push to extend President Emmerson Mnangagwa’s term to 2030 has stirred outrage, anxiety, and exhaustion.
Picture illustration of President Emmerson Mnangagwa shredding the constitution (Graphics by Gabriel Manyati)

Mnangagwa’s midnight amendments: Why Agenda 2030 is already a done deal

0
In Zimbabwe, constitutions are revered in theory but are in practice rearranged at the whim of the ruling elite. I therefore pen the words below with a heavy heart, fully aware that they may very well induce learned helplessness in the reader thanks to the fatalistic tone.

Don't miss a story

Breaking News straight to your inbox.

No spam just news !

589 COMMENTS

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
589 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
3 years ago

When you do meet him,you’re all smiles, but you bully a helpless patient.

3 years ago
Reply to  Siwela Kennedy

Siwela Kennedy kkkk apa wataura chokwadii

3 years ago
Reply to  Siwela Kennedy

Siwela Kennedy no one was bullied.

3 years ago
Reply to  Siwela Kennedy

Siwela Kennedy helpless patient why she didn’t go to the hospital of educated people 😒

3 years ago

Iiiii zvakaoma . Pamwe vanhu tingachangamuka tikavhota nehungwaru

3 years ago

Isa bill Kuna Garwe mongodhodza mari muma account awo

Havasi vakuzviwanza here chiremba ava

3 years ago

Kevin Virimai Zvenyika No ndotoona varikuita zviribhoo

Kevin Virimai Zvenyika tikugadzirisa nyika kkkkkk

3 years ago

Better

3 years ago

Interesting. I will be following closely.

3 years ago

Results is that ,all will end here on earth nomatter how rude she’s.

3 years ago

Thts a better deal that should be formalised

3 years ago

😂😂😂😂 Jamwanda we are waiting for your response

3 years ago

😁😁😁😁😁 haaaaaaaayaaaaa

3 years ago

Good idea💙

3 years ago

Thus very good Doc but you must tell your former president Thabo Mbeki that the whole Zimbabweans will never forget and forgive him . He created all this mess . Zimbabwe could have been somewhere but because of him we are like dogs .

3 years ago
Reply to  Enias Gapare

Enias Gapare it’s called spoils of war , South Africa did what everyone could have done ,they saw an economic opportunity in the face of our squabbles, ZANU PF will do anything to win an election and nothing for the economy,the political polarization that we have in Zimbabwe is never meant to be solved by external parties,but to be sustained,when a country is a net importer of goods it directly becomes a net exporter of jobs,we are exporting our own jobs and bringing poverty home

3 years ago
Reply to  Enias Gapare

Enias Gapare Thabo was there with each Zim election since 2008?

3 years ago
Reply to  Enias Gapare

Enias Gapare I agree but it’s painfull someone busy defending Mbeki as Zimbabweans we still have a long way supporting each other is a problem.Kunyebera kungwara ndokwakatisvitsa pano and hatidzidze.Gore tatichadzidza kubatana zvichaita.

3 years ago
Reply to  Enias Gapare

Tandiwe MaKay The 2008 election which was won by Morgan Richard Tsvangirai was stolen through Thabo Mbeki who was sent by the UNITED NATIONS to monitor the election , and he lied that Mugabe won and the election where free and fee.

3 years ago
Reply to  Enias Gapare

Enias Gapare No other elections after that? If so Thabo was there again to manipulate?

3 years ago
Reply to  Enias Gapare

Cathrine Nyarai Gatsi we have to go and vote . Vote for a total change.

3 years ago
Reply to  Enias Gapare

Tandiwe MaKay unfortunately you are not a Zimbabwean . You know nothing about politics in Zim . So you rather make a research otherwise I am westing my time .

3 years ago
Reply to  Enias Gapare

Enias Gapare My question remains, did Mbeki manipulate the votes after 2008? Did you vote wisely or you were gallavanting around the world not voting for the right party? Stop playing victim for a century go register to vote.

3 years ago
Reply to  Enias Gapare

Tandiwe MaKay voting did it anything till today ZEC is of young blood who are related to the ruling elite

3 years ago
Reply to  Enias Gapare

Tandiwe MaKayTandiwe MaKay pliz stop yo nonsense

3 years ago
Reply to  Enias Gapare

Tandiwe MaKay ukundipa hasha iwe ndatadza kudya sadza izvezvi

3 years ago
Reply to  Enias Gapare

Cathrine Nyarai Gatsi you have no idea how deep the roots of the problem is , Zimbabwe is long sold my friend

3 years ago
Reply to  Enias Gapare

Tandiwe MaKay Ask yourself why after 2008 elections more Zimbabweans flock to SA

3 years ago
Reply to  Enias Gapare

Ndiye akauya akati itai inclusive government anyara kutaura kuti budie vadyiwa

3 years ago
Reply to  Enias Gapare

Cathrine Nyarai Gatsi this Mckay does not think. She is really stupid.

3 years ago
Reply to  Enias Gapare

Enias Gapare u can’t do anything to Zanu,only God will vote they off,Zanu pf never won elections since 2000,so don’t blame Zimbabweans blame Sadc coz they allow nonsense

3 years ago
Reply to  Enias Gapare

Enias Gapare here comes next year let’s see if Mbeki will be In Zim.Lets hope all of you will go home and vote for better.

3 years ago
Reply to  Enias Gapare

Enias Gapare how can you blame Mbeki at least he tried his best. It was for the first time in Zim to vote in that way. Votes counted at a polling station

3 years ago
Reply to  Enias Gapare

Nkosie Tan-tanNkosie Tan-tan had already done his job and get his payment from ZANU PF .

3 years ago
Reply to  Enias Gapare

Clement Mpofu you don’t even know what he did to the people of Zimbabwe . Just give me a call I will tell you everything . In shot Mbeki is the enemy of the people of Zimbabwe . He prefers his mining business in Zimbabwe than the freedom of our people . Only God knows how he will punish that evil Mbeki.

3 years ago
Reply to  Enias Gapare

Nicholas Ndlovu I’m angry Nicho . One day they will go . Morgan Tsvangirai won but that Mbeki guy sold us . The heartless man . I hate him .

3 years ago
Reply to  Enias Gapare

Chikanga Tessy En She’s an idiot she knows nothing about politics . Trying to protect the evil man who sold the whole country because of the love of money shame .

3 years ago
Reply to  Enias Gapare

Cathrine Nyarai Gatsi that Tandiwe Kay same group with Mbeki .

3 years ago
Reply to  Enias Gapare

Nkosie Tan-tan Rubbish, let’s watch how things will end in SA with this looting of funds and corruption.

3 years ago
Reply to  Enias Gapare

Enias Gapare very true and it’s still going even with this current government

3 years ago

Hope it will work when they can’t pay their own doctors teacher etc lam just thinking zanu pf is a mess

3 years ago

Mutimba Yeukai Forget it will work definitely and it’s not that the Zimbabwe government can’t pay doctors,teachers etc. They just don’t want to pay them

3 years ago

Good move, now let see who is caring for their citizens

3 years ago

Good move but if we are undocumented, how would she defferentiate Zimbabweans from e.g Mozambicans who speak Shona

3 years ago

Patrick Hailstorm kkkkkkkkk dnt kill me wth a laugh…

3 years ago

Good question broo big up

3 years ago

Patrick Hailstorm
In Botswana they deport Tanzanians in Ramakgwebana border Post
Tanzanians they use to register their names in police as shonas

3 years ago

🤣🤣🤣

3 years ago

Senele Senele you see now🤷‍♂️

3 years ago

Precious Ndlovu maMoyo how are you sis wam

3 years ago

Patrick Hailstorm I’m fine tnx and you broo

3 years ago

Precious Ndlovu am good sis.

3 years ago

Senele Senele How is being a shona an advantage to a Tanzanian when there country is wealthier than Zimbabwe?

3 years ago

Iam beginning to love Phopie. She is standing up for Zimbabweans against the insensitive Mnangagwa government

3 years ago

Her own Anc Cdes who got business interests in Zimbabwe are the ones who will block that idea those are the same people who have been protecting ZANU for two decades now.

Good idea but those ANC pple benefitting from ZANU PF will not agree with that, come elections can the ANC nominate her to be part of the SADC election observer and she must give back a true report as she is doing now.

3 years ago

I doubt it will work. Their president said people do not understand the relationship between ZanuPF and ANC.

Nobuntu Mfenguza yaa pakaipa

3 years ago

Nobuntu Mfenguza that should work, all they need is a memorandum of understanding or a written agreement….

3 years ago

Their president knows what’s going on and he is supporting that lady so ti will definitely work

3 years ago

Nobuntu Mfenguza actually,there’s a difference between political parties and governments eg zpf gvt and zpf are two different entities

3 years ago

Nobuntu Mfenguza their president is supportive of what she is doing and even suggested that the issue be brought forward at the SADC head of state summit.

3 years ago

Nobuntu Mfenguza That relationship is very bad .

3 years ago

Nobuntu Mfenguza that clealy shows there is no longer relationship Rhamathuba is not just an ordinary person he is the ANC leader even Mantashe is doing that

Nobuntu Mfenguza its not about ZANU PF AND ANC but RSA and ZIMBABWE

3 years ago

Pfuti Hamurevesi deplomatic relationship is falling slowly

3 years ago

Tawanda Dhuvai Mpofu on this matter it’s not about deplomatic relations but an issue regarding illegal migration

3 years ago

Pfuti Hamurevesi When?

3 years ago

Nobuntu Mfenguza if there is relationship, why they don’t tell them the truth .She must send the bill to Zim government. My sister u did well they are out of order let them pay nothing for mahala

3 years ago

Davison Janhi when what make sense.

3 years ago

Nobuntu Mfenguza here we talk about money not relationship

3 years ago

Yes, that’s more appropriate!The top officials also seek medical attention abroad using tax payers’money!!

3 years ago

I think it is a good idea ..now when can SA expect a bill for the delay they asked for delay in our land reform programmes ..something that did not only delay but destroyed relations between zanu and ZAPU leading to a bloody genocide? Send the bill

3 years ago

The whole S.A. for Zimbabwe government to feel the heat.

3 years ago

Can ANC elect this MEC to head the election observer mission into Zimbabwe election hope we can hear interesting results from the south African observer mission

3 years ago

Batsi Andrew Makoni its a good plan but anc will not allow it. It will be their down fall.

Samilani Nyachopera You really don’t understand politics ANC want to push munangagwa to admit that he failed.They will bill him then he will fail to pay the bills SADC yoti now we have clear evidence that you guys are failing to run yr gvnment

3 years ago

Batsi Andrew Makoni shes right

3 years ago

Batsi Andrew Makoni good observations 👷‍♂️

3 years ago

Batsi Andrew Makoni the lady is a true African

Ukabudirira kuzviita unenge wagona chose

3 years ago

Batsi Andrew Makoni true.. Misplaced priority apapa

3 years ago

She must not buy food anywhere in Zim

3 years ago

Good plan 🤞

3 years ago

Baba Wayne NaTawa Ngwarai so, you think you’re the best in politics? You’re just like anybody else. Sorry.

3 years ago

Batsi Andrew Makoni now thats a very fine idea

3 years ago

Kkkkkk

they are going to abduct her or give her poison,zimbo inteligency is gud in doing tht,she wont even see the election day.

3 years ago

Batsi Andrew Makoni thats a great idea not to send Mbeki

3 years ago

Batsi Andrew Makoni kkkkkkk yaa size

3 years ago

Batsi Andrew Makoni That is a good plan

Baba Wayne NaTawa Ngwarai a provincial health personnel cannot bill a foreign country!
She is just a mumbling moron!

3 years ago

Batsi Andrew Makoni I can offer kuti agare kumba kwangu anenge ari safe hake

3 years ago

Batsi Andrew Makoni yes good idea bro fuck zanu of

3 years ago

Batsi Andrew Makoni forget it. She’ll receive a fat check before leaving SA, a booster check upon arrival in Zim, and the mother of all fat checks just for declaring elections ‘free and fair’. Corrupt politicians will do anything, but reforms, to stay in power.

3 years ago

Thembekile Dzenga or worse, threaten her family. Killing people is a hobby to them.

3 years ago

Kosimasi Mashiri ma C10 tibvirei, kure uko

3 years ago

Batsi Andrew Makoni if possible create a petition, we will gladly sign it in our numbers

3 years ago

Batsi Andrew Makoni they are so many
Lindiwe Zulu once said there is no such elections in a violent environment.

3 years ago

Batsi Andrew Makoni vanopihwa gwalangwa zvikashakwa

3 years ago

She is crazy, we going to the private doctors but she is going to regret all this nonsense it’s just the matter of time

3 years ago
Reply to  Tendai Bodo

Tendai Bodo who is the loser here. The truth is our country must be responsible. We can’t say she’s crazy and yet we are beggars

3 years ago
Reply to  Tendai Bodo

Patricia Ngwenya I’m not bugging anything I’m not employed in any South African company or industry

3 years ago
Reply to  Tendai Bodo

Patricia Ngwenya every body is a beggar nometter how rich

3 years ago

They cant pay their own civil servants

Donate to Nehanda Radio

Latest Recipes

Latest

More Recipes Like This